Claude, Codex or ChatGPT: test before you subscribe
Compare supplier quotes with the AI you already have. Check its calculations, missing data and duplicates before choosing another tool.
Before buying another subscription based on a general ranking, give an AI you already have one small work task and check the result. Compare the usable output, not an impressive first answer.
Task: choose a tool for a specific process without unnecessary purchases or setup.
Result: a checked table of supplier quotes and a short evaluation record: what passed, what is missing and whether another tool is worth testing.
Useful if: you are choosing AI for documents, calculations, code or work in connected services.
What you need: one AI you can access. You only need a second tool for an actual comparison; without access to it, there is no basis for declaring a winner.
Limit: one test can expose errors, but it does not establish that a model is better at every task.
Choose the working mode, not just the name
Claude and ChatGPT provide access to models and work tools. Claude Code and Codex are designed for projects and code. What a particular session can do depends on its version, mode, plan and authorized connections.
| Your task | What to check |
|---|---|
| Text and documents | Facts, required format, references to source data and how much a person needs to edit |
| Tables and calculations | Formulas, units, currencies, missing values and duplicates; the result must be reproducible by recalculation |
| Software changes | Project access, a clear diff, tests and reversibility; more than a statement that it is “done” |
| Actions in services | The specific connection, its permissions, confirmation of the outcome and limits on actions |
If you need to calculate totals for three quotes, start in chat. If dozens of files in different formats arrive every week, a repeatable file-processing workflow may be useful after testing. Do not buy a development tool just for a single price comparison.
Give this task to your AI
This is a self-contained training test. All quotes are fictional; it needs no access to procurement systems or correspondence.
Check whether the AI I already have is suitable for comparing supplier quotes. Calculate the totals, then produce a tool-evaluation record. Do not place an order or contact suppliers.
First, name the product/mode and the tools available to you, but only if you know them reliably. Do not guess the model, plan, usage cost or execution time. Use the mode already available; do not install or buy anything.
TRAINING TASK:
We need 20 identical chairs. All amounts below are in UZS and include tax. Assume lead time and quality are equal for this test only.
A1: supplier A, 120,000 per chair, delivery 100,000 for the entire order.
B1: supplier B, 115,000 per chair, delivery 300,000 for the entire order.
C1: supplier C, 110,000 per chair, delivery cost not specified.
A1-copy: an exact copy of A1, not an additional quote or an additional order.
1. Make a table with these columns: source ID, supplier, quantity, unit price, delivery, total cost and data completeness. Show the formulas. Flag duplicate A1-copy separately; do not count it twice. Do not replace an unknown delivery cost with zero.
2. Name the cheapest quote for which the full total can be calculated. Explain separately why you cannot choose a final winner among all three without clarifying C1. Do not promise quality or stock availability based on price data.
3. Independently recalculate the totals with an available calculator/code tool, if you have one. Otherwise, show the arithmetic for manual checking and state that independent recalculation with a tool was not performed. Do not present a second text response as an independent check.
4. Provide an evaluation record with these fields: product/mode; actual access; calculation check; handling of the missing value; handling of the duplicate; human edits; review time; observed usage/cost. Mark unknown fields “not measured.”
5. Prepare exactly the same input and criteria for a second AI. If authorized access is available, run a separate test; otherwise, mark the second column “not tested.” Do not simulate another product's answers. Do not ask to connect real procurement systems for a training comparison.
6. Recommend keeping the current tool, testing another one or postponing the choice. Base the recommendation on a specific defect or a passed check, not the brand. Before a live pilot, agree the data, recipients and any new connections/costs. Use a copy first; do not change live files or procurement records.
Acceptance criteria: calculations for three unique quotes, a flagged duplicate, an open question about C1 and an evaluation record with an honest status for every check. End with one next step.
Expected result
- A: 20 × 120,000 + 100,000 = 2,500,000 UZS.
- B: 20 × 115,000 + 300,000 = 2,600,000 UZS.
- C: 20 × 110,000 = 2,200,000 UZS excluding delivery. The full total is unknown.
- A is cheapest among the quotes with fully calculable totals. C is cheaper than A only if delivery costs less than 300,000 UZS; at 300,000, they tie. The duplicate of A does not increase the order quantity or total.
A wrong total, a missed duplicate or an invented delivery cost matters more than attractive formatting. Set a pilot rule: none of these errors on the agreed test set. This is a condition for proceeding to the next step, not a promise of error-free future performance.
How to compare costs honestly
Record staff time spent checking and correcting, repeat attempts, the available usage limit and observed charges. Do not divide a subscription price by an invented number of requests or label unknown usage cost as zero. Compare the same task, source data and criteria.
If one tool completes the task and the other has not been tested, the only conclusion is that the first tool passed this test. Check the provider's current plan before paying. This guide does not provide pricing verified as current today.
For code, use the same approach with a small task in a separate copy of the project: identical input, identical tests and a diff review. Learn more: Claude chat, Cowork and Code, getting started with Codex.
Capability descriptions: Claude Code, Codex. Check which features are actually available in your session.
Frequently asked questions
Which is better, Claude or ChatGPT?
Compare them on your own task: accuracy, ease of checking, required connections and total cost. There is no universal winner for every process.
How is Claude different from Codex?
Claude is Anthropic's family of models and products. Codex is OpenAI's agent for working with code. For a comparison of development tools, Codex and Claude Code are the more appropriate pair.
Which is better, Claude Code or Codex?
Both can work with projects and code. Use the same task to check the quality of changes, verification, time and cost. The advantage depends on the model, settings and project.
Claude Pro or ChatGPT Plus: which subscription should I start with?
Start with the features you need and the tool you already have. Check the provider's current plans and limits before paying. Do not buy a more expensive plan based only on a general recommendation.